Skip to content

Utah’s Bloodiest Secret: Mormonism and the Black Hawk War [Mormonism Live 230]

This episode of Mormonism Live, we dive into a forgotten battlefield of Utah history — the Black Hawk War — a brutal and devastating conflict between Mormon settlers and Native American tribes that has been largely buried under pioneer myths and whitewashed storytelling. Far from a few isolated raids, the Black Hawk War (1865–1872) was Utah’s deadliest and most destructive conflict, costing hundreds of lives, displacing entire tribes, and forcing Mormon settlements to be abandoned across southern Utah. We’ll explore how this violent chapter unfolded, why the LDS Church worked so hard to minimize it, and the staggering story of Antonga Black Hawk — the baptized Ute leader who fought for his people’s survival and whose remains were later put on public display like a trophy. In this episode, we ask the uncomfortable questions: How did religious manifest destiny fuel the bloodshed? Why was this “war” covered up for so long? And what does reckoning with this history reveal about Mormonism’s legacy of colonization? Get ready — this is the real Mormon history they never taught you in Sunday School.

Play

2 thoughts on “Utah’s Bloodiest Secret: Mormonism and the Black Hawk War [Mormonism Live 230]”

  1. I recently listened to a book about Jim Bridger the famous mountain man. I was surprised to hear about his interaction with Brigham Young and other early Mormons. The Mormons interactions with Bridger did not seem very “Christian “ as the Mormons basically stole a thriving business from Bridger and his partner. It gives some insight into the type of behavior that probably led to the much proclaimed persecution that I heard about so often as a youth in the 1990s.

  2. Antonga wasn’t Ute he was Shoshonean and in the episode it’s clarified a few times that Ute mis-identification is a common thing in Utah’s history. Take for example my people, the NW Band of Shoshone. For decades we were historically recorded as the “Weber Utes” and that history was debunked as being flat out incorrect. We know our history well, and I wish people would allow us to tell it. I hope this gets corrected for the Timpanogos.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.